1953-54:
R1: 10.10.1953 Middlesbrough (a) won 4-0 
Curry (3), Redhead (crowd tbc)
R2: 17.10.1953 Silksworth (h) won 11-1 
Curry (8), Bartle (2), Hymes pen (crowd tbc)
AF 16.11.1953 Sunderland (a) lost 1-2
Herbertson 16 (approx 9,000)

1954-55:
R2: 06.11.1954 South Bank (h) won 6-2 
Spears (4), Redhead, Carter (crowd tbc)
R3: 24.11.1954 Leeds United (h) won 3-1 
May, Evans (2) (crowd tbc)
R4: 08.01.1955 Blackburn Rovers (h) lost 2-3 
Redhead 17, May 78 (1,000)

1955-56:
R1: 17.09.1955 Seaton Delaval (a) drew 1-1 
Eggleton (crowd tbc)
R1R: 24.09.1955 Seaton Delaval (h) won 6-1 
Duffy (3), Winn (2), Chisholm (crowd tbc)
R2: 26.10.1955 Middlesbrough (h) won 2-1 
McWilliams, Charlton (crowd tbc)
R3: 10.12.1955 North Shields (h) won 3-1 
Eggleton, Thornton, Duffy (crowd tbc)
R4: 28.01.1956 Manchester United (a) lost 1-7 
Spears (26,282)

1956-57:
R1: 29.09.1956 Seaton Delaval (a) lost 0-1
No scorer (crowd tbc)

1957-58:
R1: 19.10.1957 Ashington Welfare (a) won 5-2
Wilson (4), Ross (crowd tbc)
R2: 16.11.1957 Seaton Delaval (h) won 6-5
Scorers tbc (crowd tbc)
R3: 18.12.1957 South Bank (h) won 7-0
Hale (4), Bell, Wilson, Ross (crowd tbc)  
R4: 04.01.1958 Manchester United (a) lost 0-8
No scorer (crowd tbc)

1958-59:
R1: 12.11.1958 Billingham Synthonia (a) won 4-0
Oliver (2), Thompson, Hodgson (crowd tbc)
R2: 17.12.1958 Middlesbrough (a) won 5-2
Mitten (3), Hodgson, Pringle (crowd tbc)
R3: 07.02.1959 Blackburn Rovers (a) 3-3
Gibson (3) (crowd tbc)
R3R: 16.02.1959 Blackburn Rovers (h) lost 1-3
Bell (crowd tbc)

1959-60:
R2: 10.11.1959 Whitehall Juniors (h) won 9-1
Peary (4), Hodgson (3), Mitten (crowd tbc)
R3: 16.12.1959 Middlesbrough (h) lost 2-3
Dalton 2(1 Pen) (crowd tbc)

1960-61:
R2: 09.11.1960 Middlesbrough (h) lost 1-4
Mitten (crowd tbc)

1961-62:
R1: 25.09.1961 Seaton Delaval (h) won 14-0
Mitten (3), Turner (3), Watkin (2), Suddick (2), Murray, Clish (crowd tbc)
R2: 18.11.1961 Corinthians (h) won 3-0
Watkin (2), O'Neill (crowd tbc)
R3: 16.12.1961 Sunderland (a) won 3-1
Gowland, O'Neill, OG (crowd tbc)
R4: 22.01.1962 Manchester United (a) won 2-1
Moncur, Suddick (11,188)
R5: 07.03.1962 North Shields (h) won 2-1 
Watkin, O'Neill (1,840)
SF1: 17.03.1962 Portsmouth (a) lost 0-1
No scorer (crowd tbc)
SF2: 04.04.1962 Portsmouth (h) won 4-2
O'Neill (2), Gowland, Watkin (2,340)
F1: 17.04.1962 Wolves (a) drew 1-1
Chapman (13,916)
F2: 02.05.1962 Wolves (h) won 1-0
Moncur (20,558)

1962-63:
R3: 19.12.1962 Barrow (h) won 3-1
Robson, Smith, Webster (crowd tbc)
R4: 25.03.1963 Bolton Wanderers (h) won 1-0
Younger (crowd tbc)
R5: 24.04.1963 Manchester United (a) lost 0-3
No scorer (crowd tbc)

1963-64:
R2: 14.12.1963 Hull City (h) won 4-1
Robson (2) (1 pen), Gulley, OG (crowd tbc)
R3: 13.01.1964 Middlesbrough (a) lost 3-5
Allen, Smith, Finnigan (crowd tbc)

1964-65:
R2: 05.12.1964 Workington (h) won 3-1
scorers tbc (crowd tbc) 
R3: 09.01.1965 Sunderland (a) lost 1-3
Allen (5,511)

1965-66:
R2: 07.12.1965 Middlesbrough (a) drew 1-1
Clapham pen (crowd tbc)
R2R: 15.12.1965 Middlesbrough (h) lost 1-4
Clapham (crowd tbc)

1966-67:
R1: 31.10.1966 Darlington (a) won 4-1
Duffy (3), Dyson (crowd tbc)
R2: 30.11.1966 Sunderland (a) lost 0-4
No scorer (crowd tbc)

1967-68:
R1: 07.11.1967 Hartlepools United (a)  won 7-1 
Duffy (4), Longstaffe, Hindson, Dyson (crowd tbc)
R?: 04.12.1967 Darlington (h) won 2-1 
Duffy, Dyson (crowd tbc)
R4: 03.01.1968 Sunderland (h) lost 0-1
No scorer (crowd tbc)

1968-69:
R2: 25.11.1968 Hartlepools United (a) drew 0-0
No scorer (crowd tbc)
R2R: 04.12.1968 Hartlepools United (h) lost 1-2 aet
Hopkinson 68 (1,000)

1969-70:
R1: 03.11.1969 Billingham Youths (a) won 5-1
Hale (2), Guthrie (2), Heslop (crowd tbc)
R2: 03.12.1970 Dec Sunderland (h) lost 0-2
No scorer (crowd tbc)

1970-71:
R1: 04.11.1970 North Shields (h) won 3-0
Guthrie, Heslop, Allen (crowd tbc)
R2: 25.11.1970 Sunderland (h) won 3-2
Ayre (2), Nattrass (crowd tbc)
R3: 23.12.1970 Gateshead (h) won 4-0
Guthrie (2), Embleton (2) (crowd tbc)
R4: 16.01.1971 Hull city (a) lost 0-2
No scorer (crowd tbc)

1971-72:
R2: 24.11.1971 Sunderland (a) won 3-2
Hope (2), Guthrie (crowd tbc)
R3: 29.12.1971 Middlesbrough (a) lost 0-1
No scorer (crowd tbc)

1972-73:
R2: 29.11.1972 Leeds United (a) won 1-0 
Brown (crowd tbc)
R3: 19.12.1972 Manchester United (h) drew 1-1 
Brown 72 (crowd tbc)
R3R: 10.01.1973 Manchester United (a) lost 1-4 
Barker (crowd tbc)

1973-74:
R2: 28.11.1973 Leeds United (a) lost 0-1
No scorer (crowd tbc)

1974-75:
R2: 19.11.1974 Consett Jnrs (a) won 2-0
Chambers, McLean (crowd tbc)
R3: 06.01.1975 Manchester United (h) drew 0-0
No scorer (crowd tbc)
R3R: 08.01.1975 Manchester United (a) lost 0-2
No scorer (crowd tbc)

1975-76:
R2: 19.11.1975 Barnsley (h) won 4-1 
McLean 61, McCaffery 67, Guy 71, Chambers 73 (crowd tbc)
R3: 15.12.1975 Middlesbrough (a) won 3-2
McLean 2, Kirby (crowd tbc)
R4: 22.01.1976 Newport County (a) won 2-1 
Chambers, McLean (crowd tbc)
R5: 10.03.1976 Bristol City (a) drew 1-1 
Guy (crowd tbc)
R5R: 15.03.1976 Bristol City (h) won 6-1 
Guy 24,25,88 McCaffery 37, 56, 59 (crowd tbc)
SF1: 24.03.1976 Wolves (h) lost 1-2 
Guy (crowd tbc)
SF2: 07.04.1976 Apr Wolves (a) lost 1-2 
Guy 88 (crowd tbc)

1976-77:
R2: 01.12.1976 Sunderland (h) lost 0-3
No scorer (crowd tbc)

1977-78:
R2: 28.11.1977 Sunderland (a) lost 1-2
McFarlane (crowd tbc)

1978-79:
R1: 04.11.78 New Hartley Juniors (a) won 6-2
Latty, Pugh, Nicholson (2), Hewitt, Hunter (crowd tbc)
R2: ??.??.1978 Hull City (a) won 3-0
Nicholson 2, Pugh (crowd tbc)
R3: 22.01.1979 Manchester City (h) drew 0-0
No scorer (crowd tbc)
R3R: ??.??.1979 Manchester City (a) lost 0-3
No scorer (crowd tbc)

1979-80:
R1 29.10.1979 Bradford City (a) won 1-0
G Walton (crowd tbc)
R2 24.11.1979 Yorkshire Amateur (a) won 3-2
Haddock (2), Thomson (approx 300)
R3 08.01.1980 Hartlepool United (a) lost 0-3
No scorer (crowd tbc)

1980-81:
R2: 03.12.1980 Blackburn Rovers (a) won 4-0
D McDonagh, G Reay, S Snyder, G Walton (crowd tbc)
R3: 05.01.1981 Burnley (h) won 2-0
G Walton, P Grigg (crowd tbc)
R4: 27.01.1981 Manchester City (a) lost 2-5
G Reay, P Grigg (crowd tbc)

1981-82:
R2: 02.12.1981 Doncaster Rovers (a) drew 1-1
Bell (crowd tbc)
R2R: 07.12.1981 Doncaster Rovers (h) won 2-0
Snyder (2) (crowd tbc)
R3: 26.01.1982 Leeds United (h) drew 2-2
Ferris, Willis (crowd tbc)
R3R: 01.02.1982 Leeds United (a) lost 2-3
Thompson (2) (crowd tbc)