Main Page

Quick Links
   Fixtures
   Reports
   Players
   Transfers
   Rumours
   Table
   Stats
   Reserves
   Academy

The Rest
   Archives
   Club info
   Last Season
   SJP
   Unlikely Lads


Season 2024-25
Nottingham Forest (h) Premier League

 


Date:
Sunday 23rd February 2025, 2pm
Live on Sky Sports

Venue:
St. James' Park

Conditions: Bemusing



Newcastle

Nottingham Forest

 

4 - 3


 

Teams

Goals

6 mins Tino Livramanto took a throw-in on the left touchline midway in his own half, reaching Jacob Murphy who was facing towards his own goal and shadowed by Callum Hudson-Odoi.

The Newcastle man misjudged the bounce of the ball and steered it straight into his opponent, who was quickly away from him and heading towards the home goal. With team mates in good positions either side of him, Hudson-Odoi instead added to his catalogue of strikes from outside the box with a low right-footer that found the corner of the Leazes End net.

There was a case that Dan Burn may have obscured the view of Nick Pope, but the starting position of the recalled custodian looked suspect, seemingly too far towards his left post for his dive to be anywhere near the shot - certainly not in the middle of our goal.
0-1

23 mins Anthony Gordon made the most of minimal contact with Ola Aina on the United left outside the Forest box, winning a free kick that Lewis Hall fired towards the back post and Bruno Guimaraes, whose header across goal bounced in the six yard box and flew over the head of Burn.

Alexander Isak stuck out a foot on the left corner of the six yard box to slow the progress of the ball, allowing Joe Willock to take possession under pressure from Elliot Anderson. Willock moved towards the edge of the area before channelling the ball back to Hall, who supplied a first-time centre.

That bounced once en route to the unattended Lewis Miley, who controlled it his right foot before steered it into the far corner of the Gallowgate End net with 15 yard left-footed shot that went through the legs of both Chris Wood and Nikola Milenkovic.
1-1

25 mins A short pass from Hall to Gordon on the United left in their own half led to the latter sending a through ball down that flank to the advancing Isak, who had Milenkovic in close proximity.

United's top scorer took a touch before back-heeling the ball into the path of Hall, who had continued his forward run and had Willock alongside him infield. Arriving in the opposition box, Hall spotted the unmarked Jacob Murphy racing to the back post and the pass reached his intended target via a kind deflection off Murillo.

With both Anderson and Nicolas Dominguez in pursuit as the ball dropped into the six yard box but looked to be missing the goal, Murphy calmly touched the ball home with his right thigh. Amid hopeful claims of handball from Forest players, the referee's assistant on that side of the field indicated what part of Murphy's anatomy had got the vital touch.
2-1

33 mins Willock and Gordon exchanged passes to the left of the Forest box, the former laying the ball back to Hall, who instantly pumped in a cross from roughly the same position that had prompted his side's opening goal.

This time Aina intervened to block the ball, jumping but crucially leading with his right arm and seeing the ball hit his crooked right elbow. That prompted an almighty shout of "handball" from the crowd that was mirrored by claims from the Newcastle players.

A VAR check ended with referee Jarred Gillett consulting the pitchside monitor in front of the East Stand, Bruno Guimaraes repeatedly re-enacting the illegal action of Aina - complete with jump.

Alexander Isak took the penalty, netting with a curious semi-panenka effort that beat Matz Sels for height, a right-footed conversion looping over the 6 foot 2 inch tall 'keeper, who reached the ball with his right hand as he fell back but could only help it into the net.
3-1

34 mins Pope began the move by bowling it out to Hall in the left back position and he released Willock with a precise pass as he motored over halfway with Wood trailing in his wake.

Slipping the ball to Alexander Isak who had moved to his left in the Forest box, the Swede hit a first-time effort that struck the boot of Murillo and looped over Sels into the net.
4-1


Make Alexander Great Again

Half time: Newcastle 4 Forest 1

63 mins
Anderson's out-swinging right-footed corner kick from the Forest right was helped on by Anthony Elanga and reached Wood beyond the far post. He knocked it into the six yard box where Milenkovic was able to backheel it into the net from close in, Miley the nearest to him. 4-2

90 mins
Elanga sent over another corner from the right, Harvey Barnes heading the ball out from the front corner of his own six yard box a short distance to Morgan Gibbs-White. He shot towards goal and Pope looked nowhere near it, only for the effort to strike Fabian Schar in the six yard box.

First to react to the loose ball was substitute Yates, who poked home from five yards out.
4-3

Full time: 
Newcastle 4 Forest 3

We Said

 
Eddie Howe said:

"It was a crazy game. We've seen the best of us and the worst of us, really, in two 45 minutes.

"I thought we were outstanding in that first half, everything that we weren't against Manchester City in our last game: dynamic, fluid, played with speed intensity, we sprinted. We attacked really well.

"But we didn't sustain it in the second half. We lost momentum and then couldn't recapture it.

"There's always relief when you win. It doesn't matter whether you're one goal or five goals up.

"We have to remember we did win the game, even though the feeling is probably very different after watching the second half.

"The challenge that we need to pose each other, really, as a group is to find solutions in those moments to help the players. That's what I'll go away now and try to figure out.

"This has happened too many times this season, where we've been inconsistent game-to-game, but we've been inconsistent in-game as well.

"Ultimately we've won the game, so I have to be very, very pleased. That was a tough game – we knew it was going to be – but the players were magnificent in their response to conceding, so loads of good stuff to take away and of course some stuff to improve.

"I am trying to control my thoughts and stay positive. We didn't manage the game well but overall we are happy with the win.

"It was always a difficult game and when they took the early lead you know you have a big task. I thought we were great with the ball and looked dynamic, but then a couple of frailties showed in terms of defending set plays.

"When you win and you have things to improve, that is a good starting point. That's what I'll take away from today.

"We can reflect on that 45 minutes and there are things that we can do better. We pride ourselves on doing better and getting the details right.

"It was good to see the chairman but he might have heard a couple of swear words from me. I think he was in the same sort of emotional state though.

"It’s probably why I do love management, even though I hate it at the same time in moments.

"The elation which you feel for a split-second on some of the performance in that first half, the pride you see in the players doing well is then counteracted with all the feelings that the supporters feel, really, watching that game.

"You feel you have control on the sideline, but the reality is it’s very difficult to influence the game in the way that you want to, so yes, a bit of love and hate in there.

"But ultimately again taking the bigger picture, we’ve won the game, as difficult as that second half was.”

On Champions League aspirations:

"I think there’s a host of teams that will have that feeling. We’re in there fighting and I back us if we’re fighting and showing our best qualities, as we did in that first half.

"We’ll hopefully be there towards the end fighting and competing for that place, but nothing is guaranteed. 

"It’s such a competitive league this year and you can see that from our recent home games."


On Alexander Isak reaching 50 goals:

"It’s a huge achievement, when Alex plays like he did in the first half, he’s massive for us."

On Lewis Miley:

"A really good performance from Lewis. He finished his goal really well. He can be really pleased, he's been developing really well."

On Sandro Tonali:

"He had a hamstring problem in the week, he missed a couple of days training.

"I didn't really want to risk him today but with the second half as it was we felt we needed his legs in midfield.

"He said he felt OK to play. It was a reluctant sub but I thought he did OK when he came on and touch wood he's OK."

On selecting Nick Pope:

"It was a big decision, they're all big decisions but I understand why the goalkeeper is highlighted because there's only one.

"It's always with a view to trying to pick a team to win a football match. That's what I did today.

"I value both goalkeepers that have played this year, Martin
(Dubravka) and Nick. Nick has got his strengths, Martin has got his strengths.

"Nick distributed the ball really well, he played a part in two goals today. He helps us with set plays and the physical threat, which we didn't do well enough with our outfield players. But he'll be disappointed to concede three goals for sure."

They Said

Nuno Espirito Santo said: 

"First half, clearly Newcastle better. The second half was better, but unfortunately not enough. Too bad, too soon. It's about trying to settle down, calm down and try to be ourselves. In the first half, I didn't recognise our team. In the second half, we were much better.

"I don't know, this is what I'm going to work on now. This is a game which is good to reflect on.

"It was a game of two different halves. First half, we started well with the goal but the momentum shifted and Newcastle were much better than us. They caused us huge problems, scored goals and there was a big gap in the score.

"Second half was different. It was a good reaction from us. We started and finished the second half being the better team but it was not enough.

"I would have preferred if we had 10 minutes more because the momentum was there. We created chances and were on top. Who knows, with a bit more time we could have got something from this game.”

"Of course we are frustrated. But even though we created chances, the big issue in this game for us in terms of analysis is the 15 minutes where we lost the game. That is what we have to focus on.

"We always try to be equal, at home at the City Ground and away. But it has not been like that (this was a third successive away defeat). We have been consistent at home but our away form has dropped. But we still have time and space to put that right, and that is what we are going to do.

"I'm focused on the next game. It is not about the table now. We have a lot of football to be played and we have to try to play better inside 90 minutes. That is what I am focused on.”

Stats


United's four goal burst came in an 11 minute period - one minute quicker than the 12 minutes during which it went from 1-0 to 5-0 at home to Spurs in April 2023.

Four goals were also scored by United in a 12 minute spell against Swindon Town at SJP during March 1994. That finished 7-1 to the black and whites.

An 8-2 home win over Everton during November 1959 featured four Toon strikes in 14 minutes .

The Magpies scored four goals in one half of a PL game for the first time since an 18 minute second half period against Sheffield United at SJP in April 2024 took the score from 1-1 to 5-1. 

Alexander Isak
scored his 49th and 50th goals in the Premier League for Newcastle, becoming only the second player to reach the half century after Alan Shearer. He also matched the 50 goal haul recorded as own goals scored in our favour. 

The Swede now has 19 PL goals this season and 21 in all competitions - four less than in 2023/24.

He's the first Magpie to hit 20 league and cup goals in successive seasons since Shearer in 2002/03 (25) and 2003/04 (28).

Isak is the 22nd Newcastle player to reach a half century of top-flight league goals for the club:

William Appleyard, Peter Beardsley, Jimmy Boyd, Hughie Gallacher, Neil Harris, James Howie, Alexander Isak, Vic Keeble, Malcolm Macdonald, Tom McDonald, Jackie Milburn, Bobby Mitchell, Ronald Orr, Jock Peddie, George Robledo, Pop Robson, Jackie Rutherford, Stan Seymour, Alan Shearer, Albert Shepherd, John Tudor, Len White.

Nottingham Forest are Isak's joint favourite opponents, his fifth and sixth PL goals against the Tricky Trees matching the half dozen he's bagged against Spurs.

The half century comprises 35 shots, nine penalty conversions and six headers.

Lewis Miley doubled his PL tally following a shot at home to Fulham back in December 2023. They were both scored at the Gallowgate End, as was his strike against Bromley in this season's FA Cup.

Jacob Murphy hit his fifth PL goal of the season; his career best to date, eclipsing the four in 2022/23. He now has 16 to his name in that competition, taking him level with current colleague Fabian Schar and one ahead of Andy Carroll.

Newcastle recovered from going 0-1 behind to win for the seventh time in all competitions this season:

Wolves (a) PL Lemina 36 mins
Forest (a) PL Murillo 21 mins
Spurs (a) PL Solanke 4 mins
Bromley (h) FA Congreve 8 mins
Southampton (a) PL Bednarek 10 mins
Birmingham City (a) FA  Laird 1 min
Forest (h) PL Hudson-Odoi 6 mins

18 of United's 44 points this season have come from losing positions - five wins as detailed above, plus three draws - away at Bournemouth, at home to Manchester City and at home to Liverpool.

Following losses to Bournemouth and Fulham, United avoided what would have been three successive PL home defeats for the first time since February 2021, under Steve Bruce.

The Magpies completed their fourth league double of the season - following maximum returns against Spurs, Wolves and Southampton.

Newcastle's 568th PL home fixture saw them record their 283rd victory - and the sixth by a 4-3 scoreline. The half time score is in brackets below:

1996/97
Aston Villa 4-3 (3-1)
1996/97 Leicester City 4-3 (1-0)
2001/02 Manchester United 4-3 (2-1)
2004/05 Manchester City 4-3 (0-0)
2023/24 West Ham 4-3 (1-2)
2024/25 Nottingham Forest 4-3 (4-1)

Forest @ SJP - PL era:

20245/25 won 4-3 Isak 2 (1 pen), Miley, Murphy 
2023/24 lost 1-3 Isak (pen)
2022/23 won 2-0 Schar, Wilson
2017/18 lost 2-3 Mitrovic, Aarons (LC)
2016/17 won 3-1 Ritchie, Gayle 2 (Ch)
2009/10 won 2-0 Ameobi, Enrique
1998/99 won 2-0 Shearer 2
1996/97 won 5-0 Asprilla, Ferdinand 2, Shearer, Elliott
1996/97 lost 1-2 Ferdinand (FAC)
1995/96 won 3-1 Lee 2, Ginola
1994/95 won 2-1 Fox, Lee

Waffle

Fresh from an audience with the US President, Sunday saw Yasir Al-Rumayyan swap the White House for the black and white one, as the decision over the club's new home reached a pivotal moment.

The Newcastle Chairman could be excused for checking to see whether those stadium plans include padded seats or padded cells after witnessing a chaotic afternoon at St.James' Park, when the hosts went behind, swiftly opened up a three goal lead and then came mighty close to blowing it.


Alexander Isak's first half brace made him only the second Magpie to reach 50 Premier League goals after Alan Shearer - who was in attendance. That landmark achievement was almost an afterthought though, as a game that encapsulated United's topsy-turvy season unfolded. 

Trailing to Callum Hudson-Odoi's sixth minute shot after an error by Jacob Murphy, Lewis Miley's 23rd minute effort heralded a spectacular 11 minute spell four attacks down the left yielded four goals.
 
Miley was one of three changes to the side beaten 0-4 at Manchester City; replacing Sandro Tonali. Kieran Trippier made way for Tino Livramento and Nick Pope was recalled at the expense of Martin Dubravka - despite the latter having signed a contract extension in the run up to this game.

Within two minutes of making it 1-1, United led after Murphy atoned for his earlier rick by touching home a deflected Lewis Hall centre with his knee.

2-1 then became 3-1 when a pitchside VAR review correctly deemed Ola Aina guilty of handball; Isak's unconvincing panenka spot kick conversion barely deceiving Matz Sels.

The former Magpie 'keeper was picking the ball out of his net again seconds later; another sweeping Newcastle move ending with Isak's shot taking a touch off Murillo, cheers giving way to shouts of "dodgy 'keeper.....

Having perfected the art of unlocking Forest's defence though, Newcastle promptly lost it after half time. A rare moment of danger early on saw Fabian Schar head against the Leazes goal frame, but thereafter most of the goalmouth action came at the other end of the pitch.

A series of misplaced passes and poor decisions gave the visitors hope and they regained a foothold in the game after Nikola Milenkovic bundled home Elliot Anderson's 63rd minute corner kick.

Apprehension among home players was mirrored by fans as the feast became a famine: near-misses around Pope's goal combining with a perplexing inability to trouble Sels. We've seen this film before.

Forest duly scored a third in the last seconds after more defensive uncertainty; substitute Ryan Yates bundling in a rebound off Schar after more defensiveparalysis followed a corner kick.

Thankfully though, the 4-4 draw that had begun to look nailed on didn't come to pass - due in no small part to the mercifully short three minutes of time that was added.

Substitute Callum Wilson almost ended a breakaway with a goal but was crowded out when trying to score, when options of passing or running the clock down seemed viable.

Even if it was a game of two halves at best - a third win of the season over Nuno Espirito Santo's side was immaculately timed ahead of the twin tests against Liverpool, not to mention the FA Cup visit of Brighton and beyond that the lure of further Wembley action.

Quite what our priorities and realistic expectations are for the remainder of a season when we're fighting on three fronts remain to be seen - the team selection at Anfield on Wednesday may well give a strong indication.

Today the main plusses apart from recovering yet again from an early setback were the return to form of two players and the return of a third.

Lewis Hall bounced back from last week's setback at Manchester City to have a sizeable influence at both ends of the field, while Joe Willock belatedly showed glimpses of his former self, perhaps now trusting his own body not to let him down. 

And as for the returnee, Lewis Miley belied his 18 years with a confident and unruffled display on what was his first PL start for almost exactly a year. Selling Anderson and keeping him counts as a major plus in our mind,

Substitutions were mixed: our collective waywardness and panic-striken state prompt thoughts that Kieran Trippier would replace Tino Livramento, but the defence remained unaltered and the changes came further upfield -Sandro Tonali effective, Harvey Barnes rather less so. 

On to those that were missing and the jumpiness (or lack of it) at corners made the unavailability of Sven Botman an issue, while Bruno continues to look less influential in the absence of Joelinton.

In years to come, this game may be recalled as being pivotal to the club's destiny as was the 1-1 home draw with Liverpool in October 2017 when Amanda Staveley attended for the first time.

In the immediate future though, three valuable points lifted Eddie Howe's side from seventh to fifth, restored hopes of European qualification and left 50,000 fans mightily relieved - this club, man....

Biffa