Main Page

Quick Links
   Fixtures
   Reports
   Players
   Transfers
   Rumours
   Table
   Stats
   Reserves
   Academy

The Rest
   Archives
   Club info
   Last Season
   SJP
   Unlikely Lads


Season 2024-25
Brentford (h) Carabao Cup quarter-final

 


Date:
Wednesday 18th December 2024, 7.45pm
Live on Sky Sports+

Venue:
St. James' Park

Conditions: Fluid

Admission: £20 / £25
 

Newcastle

Brentford

 

3 - 1


 

Teams

Goals

9 mins Tino Livramento's cross from the right was cleared to the edge of the area by Nathan Collins, falling for Sandro Tonali to blast a fine first-time strike into the Leazes End net from a point level with the "D". 1-0


43 mins Anthony Gordon's corner from the right was met by Sandro Tonali, who was off the ground when he skillfully guided another first-time effort beyond Mark Flekken from 12 yards. 2-0


Half time: Newcastle 2 Brentford 0


69 mins Gordon's inswinging flag kick from the Strawberry Corner was headed away from the six yard box, dropping to Sandro Tonali, whose shot was charged down by Bryan Mbeumo. The loose ball fell in the path of Lewis Hall, who also failed to get his effort past Mbeumo.

The full back worked an opening to get a second strike on goal and when Flekken dived to smother that, Bruno Guimaraes collected the loose ball and laid it off for Fabian Schar to tuck away.
3-0


90+1 mins
Mikkel Damsgaard outwitted Bruno and William Osula inside the centre circle and pushed the ball out to Mbeumo on the Brentford right, beyond the retreating Livramento. He laid a pass across the United box despite the efforts of Dan Burn to intercept it, setting up an offside-looking Yoane Wissa to side foot into the bottom corner of Martin Dubravka's goal. 3-1

Full time: Newcastle 3 Brentford 1

We Said

 
Eddie Howe said:


"I think it’s a good performance, tough game. 

"I think the goals were hugely important. Sandro’s first one is an unbelievable strike and the second one is very difficult to do what he did in that moment.

"
Two great finishes from him and I think those early goals really helped us, could’ve been more in the second half but we’re delighted to get through.

"I think it’s brilliant to see from my perspective. He’s a big signing and you want your big signings to do well and settle quickly.

"He’s been here a while, but has had very little football. Nights like tonight will build connections with him and the supporters even stronger, I’m just really pleased for him on a personal level.

"The tweak in position has definitely helped him, he is a lot more comfortable when he is deeper on the pitch.

"He is showing all the qualities that we knew when we signed him. It is just about finding the right balance for him and the team.

"I think my focus was just on tonight and trying to get through. Of course we’ve been able to do that, then you’re looking at the draw and seeing the teams left in.

"It’s going to be a really tough game in the semi-final, but I think for us to be there is the most important thing.

"We’ll take on whoever we get and do our absolute best to try and get through to a second final, that would be an incredible thing."

On further Carabao Cup suspensions (Sean Longstaff was banned tonight):

"Bruno and Fabby are two massive players for us. They’re very consistent performers and we’re going to miss them massively, but that’s what the squad is for.

"It goes without saying that you want your best players available for the biggest games, and they’re two huge players for us. But we just have to accept it. There’s nothing we can do about it, we just have to get other players ready to perform.

"I thought Joe Willock looked bright when he came on today, so that’s a big plus for him. Sven (Botman) is not too far away, and hopefully that can be added competition for the centre-back positions.

"We have players returning from injury, and hopefully the likes of Sven came make a big difference. 

"Then we should also have Emil Krafth back in the not-too-distant future. I think Emil could be back
(for the semi-final). 

"He’s improving nicely. He’s still some weeks off, but by the time that comes around, he could be available.”

On Joelinton's injury:

"Joey had a cut to his ear, which I think was quite nasty, and he’s gone away to get that looked at."

They Said

Thomas Frank said:

"We on the day met a better team than us, we lost fair and square over the 90 minutes.

"I think the main bit I'm disappointed with is the defensive side of the game, we gave - in my opinion - three soft goals away that we can't give away.

"We need to avoid all three and they are definitely avoidable, so that's the disappointing thing that we couldn't do that because it gave us a mountain to climb.

“Overall, you can’t go to St James’ Park and concede the three goals we conceded. We need to do better. I will look into it, everyone needs to look into it, there’s no doubt about it.

"It sounds a bit crazy maybe but, beside the two goals in the first half, they had nothing.

"In these cup games you need to try to stay in the tie and hopefully be better in the second half, but we gave two bad goals away and then the third one too.

"Our goal for 3-1 was a beautiful goal, so now imagine if it was only 2-1. The pressure builds in the last four or five minutes and you never know what can happen. That is the irritating part but it is what it is.

"I said to Eddie that I hope they win it because we need a bit of change, eh? With Liverpool and Arsenal winning and Manchester United and Tottenham to play. 

"Why not give a change, I think It’d mean more to the Newcastle supporters than the rest. I give them my best support.”

Stats


It's now nine league and cup games without victory on Tyneside for the Bees, whose sole success came in their maiden visit back in September 1934, a mere 90 years ago.

Bees in Toon - all-time:

2024/25 won 3-1 Tonali 2, Schar (LC)
2023/24 won 1-0 Wilson (PL)
2022/23
won 5-1 Bruno 2, J.Murphy, Almiron, og (PL)
2021/22 drew 3-3 Lascelles, Joelinton, ASM (PL)
2016/17 won 3-1 Clark, Gayle 2 (Ch)
2001/02 won 4-1 Ameobi, Bellamy 3 (LC)
1992/93 won 5-1 Kelly, Bracewell, Clark 2, Lee (D1)
1954/55 won 3-2 Curry, Hannah, Mitchell (FA)
1947/48 won 1-0 Woodburn (D2)
1934/35 lost 2-5 Gallantree, Kelly (D2)

Sandro Tonali netted his second and third goals for Newcastle in the same Leazes End net that he'd made a scoring debut against Aston Villa in the Premier League back in August 2023. 

Fabian Schar hit his second goal in this competition, having netted from the penalty spot during the Third Round victory over AFC Wimbledon. The Swiss defender gave himself an early 33rd birthday present with his 19th goal for the club in league and cup outings.  

Newcastle's 12th appearance in the quarter-finals of the League Cup became their third success at that point, all of which have come at SJP. This is the third successive season that Eddie Howe has guided his side into the last eight:

1974/75
Chester City (a) lost 0-1 (1st replay)
1975/76 Notts County (h) won 1-0
1995/96 Arsenal (a) lost 0-2
1997/98 Liverpool (a) lost 0-2
2001/02 Chelsea (a) lost 0-1
2006/07 Chelsea (h) lost 0-1
2014/15 Spurs (a) lost 0-4
2016/17 Hull City (a) drew 1-1 (lost 1-3 on pens)
2020/21 Brentford (a) lost 0-1
2022/23 Leicester City (h) won 2-0
2023/24 Chelsea (a) drew 1-1 (lost 2-4 on pens)

2024/25 Brentford (h) won 3-1

The Magpies face their third semi-final in this competition, having won both of their previous two:

1975/76 Spurs: lost 0-1 (a), won 3-1 (h)
2022/23 Southampton: won 1-0 (a), won 2-1 (h) 
 
Newcastle are now unbeaten in their last eight League Cup home ties, which equals their previous longest run at SJP in this competition (between 1973 and 1976):

2021/22 Burnley drew 0-0 (lost on pens)
2022/23 Crystal Palace 0-0 (won on pens)
2022/23 Bournemouth won 1-0
2022/23 Leicester City won 2-0
2022/23 Southampton won 2-1 
2023/24 Manchester City won 1-0
2024/25 AFC Wimbledon won 1-0
2024/25 Chelsea won 2-0
2024/25
Brentford won 3-1

This was the third meeting of these two sides in this competition;
United 4-1 winners on Tyneside in 2001 but beaten 0-1 in West London during 2020 - the latter another quarter-final tie.

Waffle

An excellent team display at St. James' Park on Wednesday night saw Newcastle deservedly reach the semi-finals of the Carabao Cup for the second time in three seasons.

A memorable first half brace from Sandro Tonali trebled his Toon tally, before Fabian Schar ended the tie as a contest after being set up by the unselfish Bruno Guimaraes.

There was time for a late consolation from Yoane Wissa after Brentford belatedly came to life, but the victory was more comfortable than Eddie Howe could have expected, after his side's recent Premier League loss at the Bees.

Fielding an unchanged side from that which defeated Leicester City 4-0 the previous Saturday, United immediately went on the offensive and Joelinton quickly had a shot blocked.

The breakthrough wasn't long in coming after Nathan Collins cleared Tino Livramento's cross from the right to the edge of the area, falling for Tonali to blast a fine first-time strike into the Leazes net.

That lead was doubled two minutes before the break when Anthony Gordon's corner from the right was met by Tonali, who was off the ground when he guided another first-time effort beyond Mark Flekken.  

Joelinton played his part in that second goal by jostling with Wissa as the ball came over to create space, but the Brazilian failed to reappear after the break - the victim of a stray boot to the head earlier in the game from Collins after a scramble in the home box.

The third goal arrived on 69 minutes following another corner, Lewis Hall's shot rebounding to Guimaraes for him to roll the ball across the six yard box and Schar tap home from point-blank range. 

A Bees side who have struggled on their travels this season were curiously out of sorts for the most part; only belatedly raising their game when 0-3 down and United had made a further trio of substitutions. 

A look at the replies to Brentford revealing their line-up on social media confirmed the suspicions that the tie wasn't a priority despite the opportunity to match their best-ever League Cup placing. 

Four changes to the team beaten at Chelsea on Sunday night had become six by the quarter hour mark when Nathan Pinnock limped off - Sepp van den Berg having already pulled up in the warm-ups. 

Ben Mee and Wissa missed half-chances before the latter took Bryan Mbeumo's pass and shot past Martin Dubravka in the first of three added minutes.

That was far too little, far too late for Thomas Frank's side though, who could have easily conceded half a dozen goals, despite top scorer Alexander Isak having a quiet night by his recent standards.  

The pick of the chances saw Jacob Murphy's shot strike the Leazes goal frame before the break and Harvey Barnes whack his effort off a post at the other end, the ball somehow missing Flekken as it rebounded back behind him.  

Guimaraes and Schar were both booked for the second time in this competition and will be suspended for the semi-final first leg. Sean Longstaff however will be eligible to play after serving his one match ban and hopefully Sven Botman will be back in the squad and up to speed by then. 

Anthony Gordon and Lewis Hall also faced bans had they received cautions against Brentford, but that doesn't now apply - meaning that yellow cards for either in the first semi-final wouldn't trigger bans in the second one.

A season that looked uncertain in the aftermath of defeat at Brentford now has more of an air of calmness around it, following back to back home wins against compliant opposition. It's as well to remember though that this has been a "one step forward, two steps back" sort of season ahead of what appears to be an eminently winnable visit to Ipswich....

Tonali's goals may have hogged the headlines, but another solid display from the Italian caught the eye - his dovetailing in midfield with the supposedly incompatible Bruno genuinely encouraging. 

Biffa