Main Page

Quick Links
   Fixtures
   Reports
   Players
   Transfers
   Rumours
   Table
   Stats
   Reserves
   Academy

The Rest
   Archives
   Club info
   Fanzines
   Last Season
   SJP
   Unlikely Lads
   A-Z Index

Season 2023-24
Manchester United (a) Premier League

 


Date:
Wednesday 15th May 2024, 8pm
Live on Sky Sports

Venue:
Old Trafford

Conditions: Leaky

Programme: £4
 

Manchester United

Newcastle

 

3 - 2


 

Teams

Goals

31 mins A goal of such stunning simple that it seemed from the other end of the ground that "something" must be wrong with it. Amad Diallo worked his way in from the right side of the field, swerving infield as he reached the box before stabbing a pass forward to Bruno Fernandes.

The ball either ran over his foot or took the merest of touches, catching out Emil Krafth, rolling past Scott McTominay and falling to Kobbie Mainoo on the penalty spot. 

With Kieran Trippier abandoning Alejandro Garnacho towards the other side of the box and making a vain attempt to reach him, Mainoo had all the time in the world to take a touch and sweep a low shot into the corner of the Stretford End goal, beyond the right hand of the diving Martin Dubravka.

Both Diallo and McTominay looked across at the linesman to confirm there was no flag - replays confirming that Trippier had played them on.
0-1

Half time: Red Devils 1 Magpies 0

49 mins A forward ball evaded Sofyan Amrabat deep into home territory and fell to Alexander Isak, who sprayed a pass to Jacob Murphy, overlapping on the right hand side of the opposition box. 

Without hesitation he dispatched a wicked low cross that fell perfectly for the arriving Anthony Gordon, who had got ahead of Aaron Wan-Bissaka to volley the ball home from six yards out.
1-1


57 mins Fernandes sent over an inswinging corner from the Manchester United left that was met at the near post by Murphy. His header arrowed diagonally across the Newcastle box, zipping behind Gordon and sitting up nicely for Amad Diallo to emphatically welly into the net. 1-2

84 mins Fernandes approached the Magpies area in possession down the left channel, playing a pass infield as Joelinton made a half-hearted approach to block him. The ball reached Rasmus Hojlund, who moved to his right with Burn and Lewis Hall between him and the goal as Trippier arrived.

What looked like a routine shot from the Dane passed through the legs of Hall and ended up in the bottom corner of Dubravka's net, the former Red Devils goalkeeper once again caught out diving to his right. What looked regrettable from the away end was unforgivable on the TV replays.
1-3

90+2 mins Gordon's outswinging flag kick from the Newcastle right was headed out of the box by Casemiro, falling to the unmarked Lewis Hall in the centre of the field. He took a touch before shovelling a shot that flew past Onana from slightly further out than his Carabao Cup strike.

For some bizarre reason, the Old Trafford scoreboard gave the goal to Tino Livramento - who wasn't on the field at that time, or even in Newcastle's matchday squad.
2-3

Full time: Red Devils 3 Magpies 2

We Said

 
Eddie Howe said:


"We had chances and I felt we could score at any moment. But we have lost the game because of how we defended their goals. We should hang our heads really. The game got away from us in key moments.

"I don't think our goal felt at risk, but we've conceded three goals and the manner of those goals is hugely frustrating.
"

On the penalty claim:

"I thought it was a penalty. I thought that’s what VAR was good at.

"I have always been in an era where the referee makes a decision and I back it. I would possibly keep it with offsides, but I want more power with referees."

On Kieran Trippier starting:

"It was dictated to us by Tino's
(Livramento) injury. (He) picked up an injury on Saturday to his ankle, so Kieran had to play when he's had limited training time. 

"Like a number of players for us this season, he's put himself forward for the group, and I think he's played well, but he was fatiguing in that moment, so we had to take him off."

On his side's away form:

"Last season we were great away from home defensively, a lot of clean sheets, maybe not true classic performances but 1-0 wins. We’ve missed that this year.

“We haven’t delivered anywhere near as many of those type of performances that you need on the road and we have to look at why, we have to look at the personnel of the team. 

"We have to look at the mentality of the group because we should be delivering better than that."

Anthony Gordon:

"I have watched it back and it is a clear penalty.

"I do not mind the referee getting the decision wrong on the pitch, but I do not understand what the point of VAR is then. It is there to correct mistakes.

"Amrabat goes down my Achilles and then pushes me in the back. Casimiro gets the ball but there are two fouls before that. I just don't see the point in (VAR).

"I knew straight away. That is why I did not appeal because I did not mind the ref not giving it. It is fast. But I will wait for the VAR to check. You can see me tell my team-mates it is a clear penalty.

"Then we carry on and I have got no sock left. How can that be possible?"

They Said

 

Erik ten Hag:

"I think we had a difficult season, but one thing was constant and that was the fans being with us and backing the team. We are very pleased with it and we want to pay them back.

"Our last game (at home): we wanted to thank them for sticking with us, we are in difficult times.

"We are in a transition at this club and the results are not what we expect. I am very pleased (to win this game). In the past months we had many games where we were in winning positions but we couldn't get over the line.

"Today was very good and we can bring Lisandro Martinez on, an experienced player and warrior in difficult moments.

"I see the positives. I see that this team is developing.

"I know the reasons why we are not performing. No team will perform when the whole back four is not available across the season. The holding midfielder is not available. Even the striker, Rasmus Hojlund, three times injured. (Marcus) Rashford also injured.

"We have had our problems across the season and that has a negative impact on the results, but down the line, you see players performing, you see players progressing, like the youngsters, and that is very positive.

"There is high potential in this club. We all know. People can see. Kobbie Mainoo. Garnacho. Diallo. Hojlund. There are players who have the class, together with the experienced players with the class, like Bruno, for instance. Andre Onana.

"I can keep going. Licha Martinez. Luke Shaw. You can say also that Diogo Dalot is playing a fantastic season, Scott McTominay also has had a very good season.

"There are many positives in this season but I cannot mention this. Do you know why? At the end of the day, we have to win trophies. And in the Premier League and the Champions League, we did not perform how people expect of us."

Stats


Kobbie Mainoo's opener was the first PL goal that Newcastle have conceded to Manchester United since Edison Cavani netted at SJP in December 2021, ending a run of 320 minutes.

Newcastle missed the chance of their first PL double against the Red Devils; they last beat them home and away in the league in the 1930/31 season. They need to emulate or better Manchester United's season-closing result on Sunday to finish above them for the first time since 1976/77.

This was the tenth time that the two clubs have met three times in the same season; Newcastle are yet to emerge with a 100% record intact.

Anthony Gordon
netted his 11th PL goal of the season and now has 12 for the Magpies in that competition, taking him level with Ruel Fox, Kevin Nolan, Allan Saint-Maximin and Steven Taylor.

Lewis Hall
scored his second Magpie goal and like the first, it came from distance at the Stretford End. The first came against Manchester United in the Carabao Cup; tonight's debut PL strike made him the 169th scorer from the 267 players to have worn our colours in that competition.

Hall is the 20th different Magpie to net this season in the PL, extending a club record that stood at 17 before the current campaign. It also equals Manchester United's record PL tally, set in 2012/13.

With one game remaining, Newcastle have now netted 32 times on the road in the PL, equal with their tally last season. Their highest away total is 34, coming in the 2001/02 season.

In all competitions so far this season, Newcastle have scored 98 goals (81 in the PL, six in the CL, six in the FAC and five in the Carabao Cup). That PL total of 81 has only been exceeded once by the club, with 82 scored in their debut season of 1993/94, which consisted of 42 games not 38.

Newcastle have conceded 340 goals during league and cup games against Manchester United, the highest total by any club. The Magpies have scored 249 times against them in all competitions.

Magpies v MUFC @ Old Trafford - PL era:

2023/24 lost 2-3 Gordon, Hall
2023/24 won 3-0 Almiron, Hall, Willock (LC)
2022/23
drew 0-0
2021/22 lost 1-4 Manquillo
2020/21 lost 1-3 Saint-Maximin
2019/20 lost 1-4 M.Longstaff
2018/19 lost 2-3 Kenedy, Muto
2017/18 lost 1-4 Gayle
2015/16 drew 0-0
2014/15 lost 1-3 Cisse(pen)
2013/14 won 1-0 Cabaye
2012/13 lost 3-4 Perch, og(Evans), Cisse
2012/13 lost 1-2 Cisse (LC)
2011/12 drew 1-1 Ba(pen)
2010/11 lost 0-3
2008/09 drew 1-1 Martins
2007/08 lost 0-6
2006/07 lost 0-2
2005/06 lost 0-2
2004/05 lost 1-2 Ambrose
2003/04 drew 0-0
2002/03 lost 3-5 Bernard, Shearer, Bellamy
2001/02 lost 1-3 Shearer
2000/01 lost 0-2
1999/00 lost 1-5 og(Berg)
1998/99 drew 0-0
1997/98 drew 1-1 Andersson
1996/97 drew 0-0
1995/96 lost 0-2
1994/95 lost 0-2
1993/94 drew 1-1 Cole





Waffle

Newcastle's European hopes still lie in the balance after a disappointing defeat at Old Trafford on Wednesday, gifting three goals to the hosts and squandering numerous chances in front of goal.

Trailing to Kobbie Mainoo's 31st minute opener after dominating the early stages, the visitors levelled just four minutes into the second period when Anthony Gordon latched on to Jacob Murphy's cross.

Parity lasted less than ten minutes however, a fine first Premier League goal by ex-mackem loanee Amad Diallo leaving Martin Dubravka completely helpless.

Substitute Rasmus Hojlund then appeared to have sealed victory six minutes before the end of normal time with what was almost his first touch, only for Lewis Hall to net from distance following a corner. 

However there was to be no dramatic late leveller and what may have been the best chance in a decade for Eddie Howe's side to claim maximum points here instead saw them leave empty-handed. 

Newcastle slipped to seventh - overtaken by Chelsea thanks to their 2-1 win at Brighton - and level on points with the Red Devils, but still ahead of them by virtue of a superior goal difference of 24.

The task for the Magpies away to Brentford on Sunday is now simple: emulate or improve on the result that Erik ten Hag's team achieve at Brighton.

That would guarantee seventh and a Conference League playoff place, unless Manchester United then overcame Manchester City in the FA Cup Final on Saturday week - earning them a Europa League spot, pushing the sixth place finisher into the Europa Conference and depriving the team finishing in seventh of European football.

The other positive scenario sees Chelsea lose at home to Bournemouth on Sunday and Newcastle to winning at Brentford to bridge the three point gap and occupy sixth place on goal difference: enough to snag either a Europa League or a Europa Conference berth depending on the Wembley outcome. 

Back to this game though and rarely have the Magpies created so many clear chances at this venue - even including their 3-0 Carabao Cup win here last year.

Gordon, Sean Longstaff and Alexander Isak all failed when one-on-one with Andre Onano, although Gordon's was due to a clear foul by Sofyan Amrabat missed by referee Robert Jones and ignored by VAR man Jarred Gillett - who presumably thought that the technology had already been scrapped ahead of next month's Premier League vote.

As well as being denied that penalty, Dan Burn's header was cleared off the line by Casemiro a fraction before crossing it, Bruno Guimaraes missed a clear header and Isak's blocked shot hit the bar. The visiting substitutes fared no better meanwhile: Joelinton's header tipped over and Miggy Almiron almost converting a Gordon cross-shot.

Despite that profligacy, it was a series of lapses at the other end that ultimately cost the black & whites dearly. The returning Kieran Trippier played Mainoo onside for the first, a poor clearing header from Murphy let the unmarked Diallo fire in the second and Hojlund was flanked by three defenders when he dispatched a low shot under the culpable Dubravka for the third.

Self-inflicted blows at both ends of the pitch tonight leave Newcastle more reliant on the efforts of others in order to achieve a tangible reward for this season. 

Questions also abound after this result: the journey to Tyneside saw many aired; the immobility of Trippier (rusty or finished?), justifications for Fabian Schar and Joelinton not starting, Isak's fitness (improved from Saturday but still not right), whether that was a £100m midfield display... and planning a whip-round for Miggy's (single) air fare to Riyadh.

What wasn't up for debate though was another disappointing away outcome when it really mattered.

Hope isn't lost though and it's now up to us - and Manchester City - to make this result immaterial. 


Biffa