Neil
Fairbairn
Karl Muir
Mark Walmsley
Chris Neil
Brian Smith
Lee Picton
Steve Cuggy
Tony Burgess
Ian Irving
Gary Middleton
Andy Bowes
Substitutes:
Boyd
for Kerr (58)
Gall for Coppinger (75) unused: Cowan unused: Grindlay
Dawson
for Walmsley (73)
Carr for Muir (75)
Bowman for Irving (80)
Bookings:
Gary Caldwell (68 )
Ian Irving (68)
Andy Bowes (86)
Sendings
Off:
Lee Picton (71)
Referee:
C.W. Oliver
Attendance:
514
Goals & Major Incidents
10 mins The referee spoke to Bryan
Kerr following a strong challenge on Tony Burgess that resulted in a melee
of jostling players. Somewhat fortunately he chose not to show a yellow
card.
19 mins A speculative pass to the onrushing Coppinger caused momentary
confusion in the Bay box, with defenders and 'keeper each leaving the
clearance to the other. Coppinger seized on the ball and had the
relatively easy task of rolling it home from the left side of the six yard
box.1-0 20 mins Within a minute of the restart, a cross from the right fell
to Bay forward Steve Cuggy, who tried to connect with it first time, but
missed narrowly. The ball appeared to strike a defender's hand but dropped
again on to the foot of Cuggy, who made no mistake the second time
with a shot from ten yards into the top left corner of Karelse's goal.1-1. 31 mins United raised themselves from a slack period of play to
challenge the Bay goal, Gavilan's shot passing well wide of the goal. 35 mins Some invention from Bonvin, who saw his backheeled attempt on
goal stopped by the 'keeper. The chance had been created by Gavilan's run
and centre from the right wing. 37 mins Another shot on goal, this time just narrowly over the bar
from Coppinger. 43 mins Almost a rare set piece success from the reserve side, as
Gavilan's corner was met by the head of Gary Caldwell, but he was unable to
direct the ball on target.
Halftime: Whitley Bay 1 Newcastle 1
57 mins Another chance from a set
piece, as Gavilan swung over a free kick from the right, given after
Beharall had been bundled over. Dimas managed to get his head on the centre
but couldn't stop his effort from rising over the bar. 68 mins More work for the referee as Gary Caldwell and ex-united
junior Karl Muir tangled, with the latter requiring treatment on his ankle.
Irving took exception to Caldwell's robust challenge and another bout of
pushing and shoving followed. Irving was then booked for laying his hands on
the United player and Caldwell carded for the original offence. 71 mins At the third attempt a goal from a set piece. Gavilan played
in a free kick from the right hand side of the field just outside the Bay
area. It initially looked too strong and long, but dropped steeply on to the
head of Steve Caldwell. His nod back across the area fell perfectly for the
advancing Bonvin, and his well-struck half-volley beat Fairbairn to
register a first competitive goal for the Argentinean. 2-1
71 mins Before the match could restart, the referee dismissed Bay player
Picton, presumably for foul and abusive language. 79 mins With the home side a man down and tiring, United began to
expose gaps in the Bay rearguard. In the move of the match, Gavilan and
Green exchanged passes as they moved toward goal, and Green saw his fierce
shot from outside the box well saved by Fairbairn. 82 mins Green again was denied by the home keeper, as his dipping
shot from distance was tipped over the bar at the expense of a corner. 87 mins Substitute Kevin Gall's persistence on the right flank
eventually saw him wriggle past a defender and pull the ball back to Dimas.
His effort was blocked, but he did well to latch on the the centre and and
fire in an attempt on goal. Final Score: Whitley Bay 1
Newcastle 2
We said: Reserve coach Tommy
Craig commented:
"I was delighted with the result for different reasons than
normal. It was not a night to attempt to play football, so I was looking for
another kind of quality.
"I was looking for courage, determination and commitment, and our
performance was full of that. Whitley Bay applied themselves very well and
it was a case of matching their commitment.
"I was pleased with our attitude. If we'd given any less we would have
lost the game. I've got to pay tribute to Whitley Bay for their
resilience."
Waffle:
A hard-fought cup tie in front of a decent enough crowd, giving Bay at least
the consolation of a few extra quid from the gate money and pie sales etc.
While the non-league club never looked like dumping their more illustrious
opponents out of the competition, they at least gave a better account of
themselves than in September's 0-3 friendly defeat by Newcastle.
With the promotion of Ameobi to the first team and loaning out of fellow
front man McMahon to Darlo, Coppinger lacked support against the burly Bay
backline, and most of United's goal attempts came from long range efforts by
their midfield players.
Referee Oliver just about kept things on an even keel, with a minor flare-up
in each half just stopping short of becoming a brawl. Bay were clearly
intent on making up for any deficiency in class with battling effort, and
this occasionally spilled over into reckless tackling that thankfully didn't
cause any injuries amongst the toon ranks.
However, the dismissal of Lee Picton immediately after the winning goal
looked a slightly harsh judgement against the underdogs, even if it didn't
have a major bearing on the outcome of the contest.
Robson and Wadsworth were watching from the stands (along with fellow
members of the Politbureau Charlie Woods and Gordon Milne), but won't really
have learned a great deal. The quality of the Caldwells is evident, and it's
now a matter of gaining further experience and building on the raw
materials. Further upfield, Green again showed some good touches, while Kerr
faded after the break. Dimas and McGuffie at present are doing a little more
than making up the numbers, but have a wide margin for improvement, while
Bonvin shows the odd touch of class and may well mature into a useful squad
player. Beharall captained the team tonight and looked ok, but for those of
us who saw his previous forays in the first team, doubts remain about his
ability and calmness against better players.
Possibly most heartening for the watchers was that Gavilan at least showed
that he hadn't forgotten how to cross a ball, and he may yet have a part to
play in the first team when Solano and Dyer take their enforced timeouts. A
few months ago, Gavilan looked a country mile away from a senior recall, but
he has gradually improved and shown flashes of the form that saw him make
two first team starts last April. Of course, the fact he's South American
will also doubtless count in his favour....